FanaticEnterprises
Customer Comments
Home
WW 2 Book List/Reviews/Recommendations
AARs
WW 2 Books-Armies/Equipment/Vehicles
WW 2 Books NW Europe/France
WW 2 Books- Desert
Designer Notes
Downloads
Customer Comments
Errata & Clarifications
Our Products
Scenario Pack Descriptions
Contact Us

Just figured I would put here the comments I receive, product reviews, AAR's etc relative to my products to give you an idea of people's thoughts and help you make a decision on whether to buy.  I will post both the negative and the positive stuff.  I hope to be able to respond where I can to your comments to assure your enjoyment of Fanatic Enterprises scenarios.

Kenn Monte 9/27/02:
 
Paul,

 I got it today, thanks. It is nicer looking than I thought. Maybe I
can play Wes a scenario from it at ASLOK.
 As far as layout, the only thing I would like to see a little
differently it so segregate the OoBs a little more. By that I mean like
SP7, where the counters are listed, but boxed. With just commas, they
run together a bit and are harder to gauge at a glance.

Other than that, good job.

Kenn
________________________________________________________
 
Also from Kenn on 9/27/02
 
Feel free to mention something about the quick and friendly customer
service; and the inexpensive shipping cost.

Order today, and plenty of time to go over before packing for ASLOK.
_________________________________________________________________
 
And more from Kenn on 9/28/02 on the VASL Setup Files
 
Now that is a great idea! I wish all the vendors would so such a thing.
How cool would OtO and OV be if VASL setup files (and the maps) were ready
when the products are.
 
_______________________________________________________________
 
From Mike Conklin on 9/28/02
 
Hi all,

Just recieved Paul Kenny's Fanatic Pack #1 in the mail. Great speed in
getting this out, ordered by Paypal on the 25th, arrived the 28th.

Printed on heavy gray paper (not card stock), 6 scenario sheets and a cover
sheet. The back of the cover sheet has a short letter from Paul Kenny, an
Anti-Tank Rifle Grenade (ATRG) rule and a DYO Walking Wounded guide.

The scenario layout looks like a blend of CH and Schwerpunket. The
historical situation and aftermath are combined (i.e., per CH), and the OBs
are text per Schwerpunket. I would have liked boxes around the individual
units of the OB, but this works. SSR then follow.

Scenario descriptions:

FE 1: A Victory for Early Polish Armor.
    Aug 15 1920, Poland vs Russia.Uses Allied Minor as Polish and Italian as
Russian. 8 turns, Maps 10 and 46. No real special rules, Poles have 5 FT17C
tanks.

FE 2: Dans La Bataille, Pour la Patrie
    May 17, 1940; German vs French. 8 Turns, Maps 4 and 12. Airsupport,
Motorcycles, Mines.

FE 3: The Border Forts
    Nov 6, 1940 British vs Italian, 7 Turns, Maps 27 and 31. Fortifications,
Airsupport, Desert.

FE 4: Whirling Dervishes
    Feb 17 1941; Italian vs French, 6.5 Turns; Maps 26, 29. Fortifications,
Desert.

FE 5: Beyond the Call of Duty
    Apr 9, 1941; German vs Yugoslavia, 7.5 Turns, Maps 11 and 18.
Fortifications.

FE6: Cavalry Charge at Mussino
    Nov 17, 1941; German vs Russian; 6.5 Turns; Maps 19 and 42. Ground Snow,
Mist, Cavalry; OBA.

FE7: Quick and Dirty
    Mar 1, 1942: Dutch vs Japanese; 4.5 Turns; Map 47; PTO; Armor on both
sides.

FE8: Soebang Serenade
    Mar 2, 1942: Japanese vs Dutch; 10 Turns; Maps 24, 37 and 38. Large
scenario, PTO, Armor on both sides.

FE 9: Blackforce Counterattack
    Mar 3, 1942: Austrialian vs Japanese; 6.5 Turns; Maps 40 and 38. PTO,
Overlay x 1.

FE 10: An Abandoned Army
    Mar 14, 1942; Dutch vs Japanese; 7 Turns; Map 32; PTO, Civ Inter,
Partisan Generation, HIP OB.

FE 11: Italian Winter
    Jan 21, 45: Italian partisans vs German and Italian; 5.5 Turns; Map 50;
Ground Snow, Overlay x1.

FE 12: Once More into the Breach
    Feb 11, 45: German vs Russian; 8 Turns; Maps 4 and 10.

All in all, a wild mix, Desert, PTO, Snow, Japanese vs Minor Allied Armor,
everything a growing boy needs. Only one scenario uses the newer not
officially released in a module maps, very few overlays, basically almost
something for everybody.

There are only two scenarios that the ATRG rule could be used, and nothing
in the SSR's that says it is to be used. Question is were they playtested
with or with the rules. Is this rule provided as just a exercise or a
suggestion?

This is a should have, only time will tell if the scenarios are winners,
yawnners or dogs, but the value is there. With shipping, $1 a scenario ain't
bad, especially since I used the buy the General for the one or two
sceanrios they had even if no other artical in the mag was about a game I
owned.

Hope this helps, looking forward the next set Paul.

Mike "Japanese vs Minor Allied Armor now there's a slugging match" Conklin
General 6+3

___________________________________________________________________

From William Stoppel

Got the scenario pack in the mail yesterday afternoon.  Excellent
product.  Looking forward to many more from you.  I really like how you have
pulled some obscure equipment, combatants and theater's for this pack.  I
was getting tired of SS against Red Guards, 82nd and the 2AD.
________________________________________________

From Lance Roberts

10/21/02

I played a few of your scenarios at ASLOK,
and just wanted to send a few comments.
 
In 'Italian Winter', I was the partisans and outright killed
80% of the German OB, and still lost (didn't use the
no boresighting errata).  I got the impression that it's
balanced towards the Germans, those tanks are tough
since you have very little that can kill them.
I hope to play it again and see if I can do better,
but can't imagine it'd be much easier with the big
kills I had in this game.
 
I also played "Quick and Dirty" and won as the Dutch,
but shouldn't have.  I couldn't touch his tanks, though
I sure tried.  In the end I got 1 half-squad through 3
residual fires to get into the hex.  Afterwards, we realized
that he made a mistake not putting the tank right in
front of the bridge, where I'd have to make a PAATC to
get into the hex.  This would have had a great chance of
stopping me.  I plan on playing it sometime in the future
to see if I'm right.
 
 

                                    

 



 

 

Enter supporting content here